Stereotypes of submission, oppression anger many
Muslim women
NADA SELAMEH doesn't hold back her opinions on the
American media. "I don't like the way they represent us," she said.
They make the American public attack us. What upsets me is the way
they portray Muslim women as being oppressed by their men."
Before 9/11, Selameh never wore a hijab, the head scarf some
Muslim women wear as an expression of modesty. But when dusty burkas
became the defining image of Muslim women during the war in
Afghanistan, the native of Dearborn, Mich., started wearing a
hijab at 26.
"I felt that I wasn't the female the media were
showing as representative of Muslims," she said.
Ironically, few knew she was a Muslim in the first place. "When I'm
not covered, I just blend in," she said. "But being covered, people
know, 'OK, she's Muslim.' But I don't have 10 kids. I'm not married.
I work. I have a master's degree."
Before she donned her hijab, Selameh was among the unveiled
majority of Muslim women in the West who are less visible than those
in burkas.
She was one of about 2,000 Arab Americans, most of them Muslims,
attending the American-Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee's annual
convention this summer. Most women were business casual —
knee-length skirts, slacks and button-downs. Designer T-shirts,
low-cut jeans and miniskirts were popular among younger women.
Selameh was one of only a handful of women wearing the hijab.
Still, she worried that "the face of the Muslim woman" would be that
of a "hijabi," not the hijabless majority.
Selameh has reason to worry. "Veiled Praise" was a recent headline
in the New York Times. "What It's Like When I Wear Hijab" was
another in the Lexington Herald-Leader. The headline "Muslim women
face decisions on traditional, modern values" appeared in the Boston
Globe, accompanied by photos of women wearing head scarves. Add TV
images of Arab women in niqabs or columns of Iranian women in
chadors — and it's hard not to say "covered" when you think of
Muslim women.
To most Westerners, "an authentic Muslim woman is always wearing a
hijab," said Asma Barlas, a Koran scholar at Ithaca College
whose female-centric interpretations of Islam's holy book have
sparked controversy in the Muslim world.
In reality, most Muslim women in the United States and in Europe
don't wear the hijab, except for worship, because they are
members of a secular majority or see themselves as cultural Muslims,
identifying more with rai music or rumi poetry than
with salah, or Scripture. Still others are devoted Muslims
but don't view the hijab as a prerequisite of spirituality.
To these Muslim women, the hijab is more than an annoying
media stereotype. It obscures their independence, outspokenness and
career-mindedness.
Without the hijab, "we don't exist. We're not allowed to be
the face of Islam," said Laila Al-Marayati, a physician and the
chairwoman of the Los Angeles-based Muslim Women's League."
An example of the media's preferred face of the Muslim woman
recently appeared in a Seattle Times story headlined "Preserving
modesty, in the pool." The piece featured a group of Muslim women
who gathered at an indoor pool once a month to swim. Before
swimming, they taped brown paper over the windows so men couldn't
see them. "Because Islam requires Muslim women to fully cover
themselves in public," the story said, "swimming in pools or the
ocean is largely off-limits for many."
The face of Munira Sheriff better reflects Muslim women in secular
societies. The recent graduate of Harvard's Kennedy School of
Government wore a midline skirt and button-down shirt when I met
her.
"A lot of people forget that everybody is allowed to interpret the
religion," she said. "I believe that Islam wants us to be modest.
And I believe this midline skirt I'm wearing is acceptable modesty
[in the United States]. In Pakistan, I would not wear this because
it wouldn't be acceptable; it wouldn't be modest there."
In rejecting the hijab as a defining characteristic of Muslim
women, Koran scholars such as Barlas contend that the head scarf is
not rooted in theology but in the traditions of male-dominated
societies. In her book "Believing Women in Islam," she argues that
neither of the two Koranic verses cited by conservatives to justify
the veiling of women specifies a preferred covering. Rather, women
should "guard their modesty" and "draw their cloaks over their
bosoms."
"There are many ways in which you can cover your bosom," a hijab
being just one of them, Barlas said. The idea that women have to
cover their head and face emerged a few hundred years after Islam's
birth and was based on the belief that women's bodies are
corrupting, a belief unsupported in the Koran, Barlas argued.
These arguments are not confined to academic circles. Muslim
moderates around the world hear and talk about them. Last year,
Barlas spoke at the annual convention of the Muslim Public Affairs
Council, an advocacy group, and spent several weeks this summer in
Indonesia talking about her interpretations of the Koran.
"Things are happening," Barlas said, "but they are slow, and they
will take time."
Barlas' story — a Muslim woman seeking to undo centuries of
patriarchy infuriates the male establishment, with some wanting her
head — is a good one. But there are lots of smart, opinionated
Muslim women in the United States with equally good stories, if only
the media drops their veil of preconceptions.